March 5th, 2008 (11:55 pm)
current location:
with Gladys
current mood: sore
current song: Sunday in the Park with George
So the Avenue Q tour premiered at the Auditorium Center last night and I had second row center tickets.
This was the third time I've seen the show and probably the second best cast (London was the best). Everyone was insanely talented but I didn't like some of their choices. I don't have my playbill in front of me at the moment, so please bear with me while I use character names instead.
Avenue Q follows the story of Princeton, a young college graduate with a B.A. in English as he starts out on the long, hard, road known as real life. The actor playing Princeton (Robert Mcloud?) did a good job making the character likeable and established a strong connection with the audience rather quickly. He also doubles as another character, Rod, throughout the show, but I felt like he didn't distinguish well enough between the character's voices. They sounded exactly alike.
The actress playing Kate Monster/Lucy the Slut was very talented. Her vocals were outstanding and her comedic delivery was rather brilliant. She did a wonderful job making the role her own and really making the audience sympathize with Kate. I loved her facial expressions for Lucy the Slut.
Nicky/Trekki Monster was rather typical. The actor I saw in London set the standard extremely high, I don't expect to ever see anyone ever come close again. His choices were so strong, and made his characters (especially Nicky) so real, that you completely forgot you were watching a muppet. This actor did not tug at the heartstrings at all, he pretty much played everything for laughs. I understand that Avenue Q is a comedy, but I really feel like there is an important message and the characters have a lot of substance that the audience can relate to and the London cast really created a wonderfully varied and textured performance. This was just a flat comedy, it was like watching an episode of South Park.
Christmas Eve was also very talented vocally. Her acting was, once again, primarily for laughs. There was no depth or substance, and she missed a lot of opportunities to really connect with the audience (again just my opinion)
The actress playing Gary Coleman, I think, was the most talented member in the cast. She was, by far, the best Gary Coleman I have seen. Her performance was the only one where I made the connection to Gary Coleman. Vocally she was one of the stronger members in the ensemble. I really hope to see her in something else on Broadway soon.
Cole Porter played Brian, and I felt he was the weakest member of the cast. Most of his jokes fell flat and I had some difficulty understanding everything he was saying.
Overall it was an enjoyable evening at the theater. I cannot believe how seamlessly the cast moves from puppet to puppet, playing two characters on-stage simultaneously, and not getting confused. The puppeteering skills were also incredible as well. It looked as if everyone in the cast spent years training to handle the puppets.
If the tour stops anywhere near you, I wouldn't pass it up, especially if you haven't seen Avenue Q. The show is a delightful commentary on modern American society, and really connects to the college, post-college graduation audiences. Is it great theatre that will be studied dozens of years from now? Probably not. But it is definitely a fun distraction from reality.